Is There Any Evidence That Meditation Helps Rheumatoid Arthritis?

Today, arthritis patients are not only moreagreeing to attend assessment sessions in
receptive to complementary therapies- what hasexchange for free MBSR training at the study's
been called alternative therapy- but actually preferconclusion.
it to conventional medicines.Both groups of participants underwent
There are many reasons for this. These reasonspsychological and rheumatological examinations at
include the adverse publicity surrounding the sidebaseline, and again at 2 months and 6 months into
effects of medicines such as Vioxx and Bextra,the study. Researchers used the Symptom
cost of pharmaceutical agents, insuranceChecklist-90-Revised, a self-report questionnaire,
restrictions that make it difficult for patients toto evaluate depressive symptoms and
get the types of medicines they need, and thepsychological distress. Overall well-being was
widely held concept that "natural" implies safe.measured by the Psychological Well-Being Scales,
As has been demonstrated on multiple occasions,made up of questions designed to evaluate
a natural remedy is not necessarily safe, nor is itpositive outlook and approach to coping with
necessarily even effective.difficulties. RA clinical factors were assessed by
However, there are natural therapies for whichthe Disease Activity Score in 28 joints (DAS-28).
there is little evidence supporting their usefulnessResearchers compared scores of psychological
in conditions like arthritis, but also a paucity ofand physical disease symptoms among MBSR
data showing they are harmful.participants with those of the control group.
Such is the case with meditation. Meditation notPatients receiving MBSR found the program to be
only is safe but has had beneficial applications inenjoyable and continued throughout the follow-up
other rheumatic conditions such as fibromyalgia.period.
A recent study has demonstrated that meditationAfter 2 months, both groups showed
may also be useful as an adjunctive treatmentimprovements in depressive, psychological, and
for rheumatoid arthritis (RA).emotional symptoms, with no significant difference
A meditation training program, calledbetween the MBSR group and the control group.
Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) wasBy 6 months, however, gains in the control group
developed by Dr. Kabat-Zinn and otherhad largely disappeared, while MBSR participants
researchers at the University of Massachusettsmaintained or improved further in psychological
Medical School. MBSR teaches participants tooutcomes. By the end of the study, the MBSR
focus the mind in a special way. This technique isgroup achieved a significant 35 percent reduction
supposed to increase clarity and calmness.in psychological distress.
Researchers at the University of Maryland SchoolThe meditation program had no impact on RA
of Medicine assessed the effect of this meditationdisease activity, measured by the DAS-28, which
therapy on depressive symptoms, psychologicalis a composite score derived from swollen joints,
distress, general well-being, and disease activitytender joints, and the erythrocyte sedimentation
among RA patients. The results of the studyrate (ESR).
indicates that there are potential benefits ofThe studies flaws include its small sample size and
MBSR and that it can be used with a conventionalthe relative homogeneity of the control group.
course of physical and pharmacological therapy.The study showed that patients with RA may
Sixty-three adult RA patients were selected tobenefit from a meditation program such as MBSR
participate in this novel pilot study. The subjectsclass. MBSR is also safe and appealing to
averaged 54 years in age and predominatelyparticipants. The lead investigator, Dr. Elizabeth
women. All patients remained under theirPradhan, also states, "For doctors wishing to offer
rheumatologist's care and continued to take theirpatients a complement to medical management,
routine medications throughout the study.mindfulness meditation may offer hope for
Thirty-one of the participants were randomized toimproving psychological distress and strengthening
receive MBSR therapy, starting with an 8-weekwell-being in patients with RA."
training course followed by a 4-month(Pradhan EK, et al. Effect of Mindfulness-Based
maintenance program. The remaining 32Stress Reduction in Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients.
participants were assigned to a waiting list,Arthritis Care & Research. October 2007).